Sadie's employee, Julie, is helping her grandmother clear out her house after she enters a nursing home. When Julie finds a candlestick hidden under the floorboards, she is shocked to notice some residue on it that resembles blood. Julie's grandfather was killed decades before and no one was ever arrested, though his wife suffered the silent accusations of many Silver Peak residents. Could the candlestick be the weapon that killed him? Julie turns to Sadie to help find answers once and for all. Meanwhile, Sadie is horrified to learn that her grandson has been arrested, under suspicion of starting a forest fire that is headed straight for town. Theo swears he is innocent, but incriminating social media photos make him the prime suspect. Convinced of his innocence, Sadie races the clock to learn who the real culprit is, before her grandson goes to jail for a crime he didn't commit.